HP 923 Ink: Remanufactured vs Original HP, Priced per Page

· Editorial policy

Shopping for this printer? See all HP 923 Ink Cartridges – 923 & 923e → Ships same day by 4 PM ET, Lifetime guarantee.

Last updated: November 18, 2026.

Quick answer: A remanufactured HP 923 black cartridge costs about 4.0 cents a page against 7.4 cents for HP's own, a saving of 46%. On the three colors the saving is only about 16%, because HP prices its 923 colors low. So the remanufactured black is the clear buy, a remanufactured 4-pack at $59.99 saves 36% on a full set, and replacing a single color with a remanufactured cartridge saves you three dollars. None of this applies if your printer is enrolled in HP+. An HP+ printer accepts Original HP ink only.

Shop the full range: HP 923 ink cartridges (black, cyan, magenta, yellow and the 4-pack).

We sell the remanufactured cartridges, so read this knowing which side we are on. The prices below are HP's own and ours, and we say plainly where the original is the better buy.

Which printers use HP 923 ink?

HP 923 fits the HP OfficeJet Pro 8120e, 8122e, 8125e, 8128e, 8130e, 8135e, 8138e and 8139e. Each takes four separate cartridges: black, cyan, magenta and yellow.

Every one of those model numbers ends in "e", which means HP offered HP+ when the printer was set up. Check that before anything else, because it decides whether you have a choice at all.

First check: is your printer on HP+?

HP+ is free and optional at setup. In exchange for an extra year of warranty and a trial of Instant Ink, the printer is limited to Original HP cartridges for the rest of its life, and that cannot be undone (HP's terms). No remanufactured or compatible 923 cartridge, from us or from anyone else, will work in an HP+ printer.

To check, open the HP Smart app and look for HP+ on the printer's page, or print a printer status report. If the printer was set up without HP+, it takes remanufactured ink like any other HP inkjet.

HP 923 prices: original vs remanufactured

Cartridge Rated yield Original HP HP cost per page Castle Ink remanufactured Our cost per page Saving
923 Black (4K0T3LN) 500 pages $36.99 7.4¢ $19.95 4.0¢ 46%
923 Cyan (4K0T0LN) 400 pages $18.99 4.7¢ $15.99 4.0¢ 16%
923 Magenta (4K0T1LN) 400 pages $18.99 4.7¢ $15.99 4.0¢ 16%
923 Yellow (4K0T2LN) 400 pages $18.99 4.7¢ $15.99 4.0¢ 16%
All four 1,700 pages $93.96 bought singly 5.5¢ $59.99 as a 4-pack 3.5¢ 36%

HP prices are from HP.com, checked October 20, 2026. Castle Ink prices are as of November 18, 2026. Yields are HP's rated figures.

Two things stand out. The black cartridge is where the money is: $17 less each time. And the colors are close enough that the decision there is about more than price.

What is the same, and what is different

Original HP 923 Remanufactured HP 923
Cartridge shell New A used genuine HP shell, cleaned, refilled and tested
Chip New HP chip Our single cartridges keep the original HP chip
Ink HP's own formula A third-party ink matched to it
Ink level gauge Accurate May read low or unknown, because the printer remembers the chip as used. Printing is not affected
Works with HP+ Yes No
Works with Instant Ink Subscription cartridges only No
Guarantee HP's cartridge warranty 1 year with us: replacement or refund, and we pay return shipping
Waste A new plastic shell each time Reuses a shell that would otherwise be scrapped

The chip row is the one that matters most for reliability. HP's dynamic security firmware is designed to reject cartridges with non-HP chips, and HP states that cartridges with new or reused HP chips are unaffected. A remanufactured cartridge that keeps its HP chip is on the right side of that line. A compatible cartridge with a cloned chip is not, which is why we would choose remanufactured over a cheaper new-build compatible on this printer. More on the terms in compatible vs remanufactured vs OEM ink.

When original HP 923 is the better buy

  • Your printer is on HP+. There is no alternative.
  • You are on an Instant Ink plan that fits your printing. At low monthly page counts a subscription can cost less than any cartridge. Our Instant Ink cost comparison has the numbers.
  • You are replacing one color and want no warnings on the screen. For three dollars more, the original gives you a working ink gauge.
  • Color accuracy is the job. For client proofs or photos you plan to keep for decades, HP's own ink is the known quantity.

When remanufactured HP 923 is the better buy

  • You print mostly black text. The black cartridge is 46% cheaper per page.
  • You replace all four at once. The 4-pack is $59.99 against $93.96.
  • The printer was set up without HP+ and you want the saving without the firmware risk that comes with cloned chips.

HP 923 remanufactured vs original FAQs

Will remanufactured HP 923 ink void my printer warranty?

No. In the US the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act stops a manufacturer from voiding a warranty because you used third-party supplies. HP can decline to cover damage a cartridge actually caused. HP+ is different: it is a program you agreed to, not a warranty term. See does compatible ink void your warranty?

Why does my printer say "used or counterfeit cartridge"?

Because the reused HP chip has been in a printer before. Press OK and it prints normally. The message is a notice, not an error. If the cartridge is rejected outright, work through HP printer not recognizing an ink cartridge.

Is print quality the same?

For documents, a properly remanufactured cartridge is hard to tell from the original. For photos and color-matched work the inks are not identical, so test before a job that matters.

What if a remanufactured cartridge does not work in my printer?

Every Castle Ink cartridge is covered for a year. Contact us with your order number and printer model and we will replace or refund it.

The bottom line

If your OfficeJet Pro 8120e or 8130e is not on HP+, buy the black remanufactured and save 46% a page, or buy the 4-pack and save 36% on the set. If you only need one color, the original costs three dollars more and is a reasonable choice. If the printer is on HP+, original is the only choice.

Related reading: compatible vs OEM HP ink, best compatible ink brands, and all HP ink cartridges.

Written and reviewed by — Founder of Castle Ink, 20+ years in the printer & imaging supplies industry.

Castle Ink

Save up to 70% on HP 923 Ink Cartridges – 923 & 923e

Remanufactured cartridges with a lifetime replacement guarantee. Order by 4 PM ET and it ships the same day. Free US shipping over $50.