Shopping for this printer? See all HP 950 & 951 Ink Cartridges – 950XL & 951XL → Ships same day by 4 PM ET, 1-year guarantee.
Last updated: November 18, 2026.
Quick answer: For an OfficeJet Pro 8600, 8610 or 8620, the set we would buy is our remanufactured HP 950XL/951XL 4-pack with original HP chips at $59.95. At a rated 6,800 pages across the four cartridges that is about 0.9 cents a page, against 3.1 cents for HP's own 950XL black. It is not the cheapest set you can buy. LD Products, 4inkjets and CompAndSave sell compatible 4-packs for $24 to $28. The difference is the chip, and on this printer family the chip decides whether the cartridge keeps working after a firmware update.
Shop the full range: HP 950 and 951 ink cartridges (950XL black, 951XL colors, 4-packs and MICR).
We sell these cartridges, so our recommendation is not neutral. To make up for that, the table below puts five other sellers next to our own prices, and three of them are a lot cheaper than we are. We explain why and leave the decision to you.
Castle Ink
Fix the error, then stop overpaying: HP ink from $6.74
Remanufactured HP ink cartridges for up to 70% less than HP charges. Same-day shipping when you order by 4 PM ET, 1-year 100% satisfaction guarantee.
Compare genuine vs remanufactured HP ink prices →
Shop all HP ink →✓ Ships same day by 4 PM ET✓ Free US shipping over $50✓ 1-year guarantee
What printers use HP 950 and 951 ink?
HP 950 (black) and 951 (cyan, magenta, yellow) fit HP's 2011 to 2014 OfficeJet Pro line. None of these printers is an HP+ model, so the Original-ink-only lock on newer HP printers does not apply.
- HP OfficeJet Pro 8100
- HP OfficeJet Pro 8600, 8600 Plus and 8600 Premium
- HP OfficeJet Pro 8610, 8615, 8620, 8625 and 8630
- HP OfficeJet Pro 8640 and 8660
- HP OfficeJet Pro 251dw and 276dw
Each printer takes four separate cartridges that feed a printhead built into the printer. For the full list, see what HP printers use 950 and 951 ink.
HP 950XL and 951XL prices compared
| Seller | Product | Type | Price | Rated yield | Cost per page | Warranty and notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HP | HP 950XL Black (CN045AN) | Original | $71.99 | 2,300 | 3.1¢ | HP.com price, checked October 20, 2026. Staples lists it at about the same price |
| HP (via Office Depot) | 950XL Black plus three standard 951 colors (C2P01FN) | Original | $168.89 | See note | See note | The colors in this pack are standard yield, not XL, so it prints far fewer color pages than the sets below |
| Castle Ink | 950XL/951XL 4-pack, original HP chip | Remanufactured | $59.95 | 6,800 | 0.9¢ | Reused HP chips. 1-year guarantee with replacement or refund. Same-day shipping on orders by 4 PM ET |
| Castle Ink | 950XL/951XL 4-pack, new chip | Remanufactured | $54.95 | 6,800 | 0.8¢ | Aftermarket chips. Same terms |
| Castle Ink | 950XL Black single | Remanufactured | $17.95 | 2,300 | 0.8¢ | 951XL colors are $15.95 each, about 1.1¢ a page |
| LD Products | Compatible 950XL/951XL set of 4 | Compatible | $27.96 (regular $36.99) | 6,800 | 0.4¢ | Lifetime warranty. LD says the cartridges "may contain new and used parts" |
| 4inkjets | LD compatible 950XL/951XL set of 4 | Compatible | $27.96 (regular $36.99) | 6,800 | 0.4¢ | Same LD-brand set; 4inkjets is run by LD Products |
| CompAndSave | Replacement 950XL/951XL combo pack of 4 | Compatible | $23.96 | 6,800 | 0.4¢ | Single 950XL black is $7.95. Volume discounts from three packs |
| 1ink | Remanufactured 950XL Black | Remanufactured | $12.99 | 2,300 | 0.6¢ | 180-day warranty |
Prices checked November 18, 2026 at the sellers' own sites unless noted. They change often. Yields are HP's rated figures of 2,300 pages for 950XL black and 1,500 for each 951XL color; some retailers now list lower numbers for the same cartridges.
The numbers are not close. A compatible 4-pack from LD Products or CompAndSave costs less than half of ours. If price is the whole decision, they win. What you get for the extra $27 to $36 is in the next two sections: a reused HP chip instead of a cloned one, and a seller that replaces or refunds for a full year and pays the return shipping.
Our pick: the 950XL/951XL 4-pack with original HP chips
The 4-pack with original HP chips at $59.95 is the set we would put in an OfficeJet Pro 8610 that stays switched on and connected to Wi-Fi, which is most of them. HP's policy statement says dynamic security blocks cartridges that use non-HP chips or modified circuitry, and that cartridges with new or reused HP chips are unaffected. A reused HP chip is what this pack carries.
The new-chip 4-pack is $5 less at $54.95. Buy it only if automatic firmware updates are already off on your printer. Singles are for replacing one color between sets: 950XL black at $17.95, and 951XL cyan, magenta and yellow at $15.95 each. Four singles come to $65.80, so the pack is the better buy.
Why the chip matters so much on this family
These are the printers where HP's dynamic security first made the news. On September 13, 2016, OfficeJet Pro 8610, 8615, 8620, 8625 and 8630 owners found that third-party cartridges which had worked the day before were reported as damaged or missing (gHacks). HP apologized and, about a month later, released an optional firmware update that removed the block (Born's Tech and Windows World). A year later a similar update blocked non-HP cartridges again.
The practical lesson has not changed since. Because the printhead is in the printer, every third-party 950 or 951 cartridge needs a chip to talk to it, and a cloned chip is what firmware updates look for. A reused HP chip is not a clone. If you buy a new-chip cartridge from any seller, turn off automatic updates first: our guide to stopping HP firmware updates from blocking your ink has the steps. If your 8610 is already showing an error, start with fixing HP OfficeJet 8610 ink issues.
How to choose an HP 950 or 951 cartridge
- Decide on the chip first. Original-chip remanufactured if the printer updates itself; new-chip or compatible if updates are off and you want the lowest price.
- Buy XL. The 950XL black is rated for 2,300 pages and from third-party sellers it costs little more than standard yield.
- Buy the 4-pack unless you are replacing a single color.
- Keep one chip type across all four slots. Mixing reused HP chips and cloned chips is a common cause of intermittent errors.
- Check the warranty length. In the table above it runs from 180 days to lifetime.
HP 950 and 951 compatible ink FAQs
Do compatible HP 950XL cartridges still work in an OfficeJet Pro 8610?
Yes, with the right chip. Cartridges with reused HP chips are the ones HP says its dynamic security leaves alone. Cartridges with new aftermarket chips work until a firmware update rejects them, so turn automatic updates off before you install them.
What is the cheapest way to buy HP 950XL and 951XL ink?
A compatible 4-pack from CompAndSave ($23.96) or LD Products ($27.96) is the lowest price we found on November 18, 2026. Our remanufactured 4-packs are $54.95 with new chips and $59.95 with original HP chips. HP's own 950XL black alone is $71.99.
Is HP 950XL the same as HP 950?
Same shape and same printers, more ink. The 950XL black is rated for 2,300 pages and each 951XL color for 1,500.
Can I use HP 952 cartridges instead?
No. HP 952 fits the later OfficeJet Pro 8710 family and will not seat in a printer built for 950 and 951. See best compatible ink for HP 952 if that is your printer.
The bottom line
For an OfficeJet Pro 8600 or 8610 that updates itself, the remanufactured 950XL/951XL 4-pack with original HP chips at $59.95 is the set we would buy. LD Products and CompAndSave sell compatible packs for less than half that, and if you keep automatic updates off they are a fair option. We have shown their prices so you can make that call yourself.
Related reading: best compatible ink brands, compatible vs OEM HP ink, LD Products vs Castle Ink, and our HP ink cartridge collection.
Castle Ink
Save up to 70% on HP 950 & 951 Ink Cartridges – 950XL & 951XL
Remanufactured cartridges with a 1-year guarantee. Order by 4 PM ET and it ships the same day. Free US shipping over $50.