Best Compatible Ink for HP 64 & 64XL (2026): Remanufactured vs Genuine Compared

· Editorial policy

Last updated: October 28, 2026.

Quick answer: For an HP ENVY Photo 7855, 7155 or 6255, the cartridge we would buy is our remanufactured HP 64XL black at $23.99 for 600 pages, which is 4.0 cents a page. Genuine HP 64XL black is $62.89 at Staples for the same 600 pages, or 10.5 cents a page, so the remanufactured cartridge saves about 62%. The 64XL black and tri-color combo at $43.99 replaces $131.78 of genuine ink. The caveat: the ENVY Photo and Tango printers are not HP+ models, but the newer ENVY Inspire 7255e and 7955e are, and an HP+ printer that was enrolled at setup accepts Original HP ink only.

Shop the full range: HP 64 ink cartridges (64 and 64XL).

We'll say the obvious thing up front: we sell these cartridges, so you are reading a recommendation from a seller. To keep it honest, the price table includes LD Products, 4inkjets, Staples, an Amazon marketplace brand and Walmart's HP bundle alongside our own listing, and where someone is cheaper than we are, we say so. The post covers which printers take HP 64, every option's cost per page as of October 2026, our pick and its trade-off, and the "cartridge problem" message that ENVY Photo owners run into.

HP+ warning for ENVY Inspire owners: The ENVY Inspire 7255e, 7955e and 7958e offer HP+ enrolment during setup. HP's FAQ says an activated HP+ printer "will require the use of Original HP Ink for the lifetime of the printer." If you want the option of remanufactured ink, decline HP+ at setup. ENVY Photo and Tango owners can skip this warning.

What printers use HP 64 ink?

HP 64 and 64XL fit HP's photo-oriented home printers from 2017 onward plus the newer ENVY Inspire line:

  • HP ENVY Photo 7855, 7858, 7830, 7164, 7155, 7158 and 7120
  • HP ENVY Photo 6255, 6252 and 6222
  • HP ENVY Inspire 7955e, 7958e and 7255e (HP+ eligible)
  • HP Tango X

Each takes one black and one tri-color cartridge. The tri-color is a single unit, so when photo printing drains the magenta, color printing stops even if cyan and yellow are half full.

HP 64 prices compared: OEM vs Castle Ink vs other sellers

Seller Product Type Price Rated yield Cost per page Warranty / notes
HP (via Walmart) HP 64 Black (N9J90AN) OEM $25.99 200 13.0¢ HP warranty; LD lists $28.99; Staples sells it only in a $56.97 2-pack
HP (via Staples) HP 64 Tri-Color (N9J89AN) OEM $32.89 165 19.9¢ HP warranty
HP (via Staples) HP 64XL Black (N9J92AN) OEM $62.89 600 10.5¢ HP warranty; LD lists $55.57–$55.99
HP (via Staples) HP 64XL Tri-Color (N9J91AN) OEM $68.89 415 16.6¢ HP warranty
Castle Ink Remanufactured HP 64XL Black Remanufactured $23.99 600 4.0¢ 1-year return window, full refund; same-day shipping on orders by 4 PM ET Mon–Fri; US phone support
Castle Ink Remanufactured HP 64XL Tri-Color Remanufactured $24.99 415 6.0¢ Same terms as above
Castle Ink Remanufactured HP 64XL Black & Tri-Color Combo Remanufactured $43.99 1,015 (600 + 415) 4.3¢ Same terms as above
LD Products LD Remanufactured HP 64XL Black Remanufactured $22.99 (list $30.99) 600 3.8¢ 2-year satisfaction guarantee; tri-color $23.99; set $43.98
4inkjets Remanufactured HP 64XL Black Remanufactured $22.99 (list $30.99) 600 3.8¢ 2-year satisfaction guarantee; ships from US
Staples Staples Remanufactured 64XL Black + 64 Tri-Color 2-pack Remanufactured $61.99 600 black / 165 color 8.1¢ 1-year replacement or money back; note the color is standard-yield 64, not XL
Smart Ink (Amazon/Newegg) Smart Ink HP 64XL Black + Color combo Remanufactured $65.99 Claims 650 black / 440 color — Warranty not stated; 30-day returns; yield claims exceed HP's 600 / 415 rating
Walmart (HP brand store) HP 64 Black + Tri-Color bundle OEM $55.89 200 black / 165 color 15.3¢ HP warranty; standard-yield cartridges

Prices checked October 2026 at the sellers' sites; they change often.

This is one of the closer comparisons we publish. LD Products and 4inkjets sell their remanufactured 64XL black for $22.99, a dollar less than ours, and their black-plus-color set is a penny cheaper than our combo. We are not going to argue over a dollar; both are good options. What you get from us is same-day shipping on orders placed by 4 PM ET Monday through Friday, a 1-year return window with a full refund, US phone support, and a promise to replace or refund any cartridge that arrives defective. Staples' own 2-pack pairs an XL black with a standard-yield color, which is why its cost per page is nearly double ours, and the Amazon-style combo is the most expensive remanufactured option on the list with no stated warranty.

Our pick: remanufactured HP 64XL black

The remanufactured HP 64XL black is $23.99 for the same 600 pages HP rates its own 64XL for, and it is a genuine HP N9J92AN shell that has been cleaned, refilled, tested and shipped with HP's original chip and printhead still attached. At 4.0 cents a page it is less than 40% of the cost of genuine. The trade-off is that LD is a dollar cheaper, and that any integrated-printhead cartridge, genuine or remanufactured, can throw the ENVY Photo's "cartridge problem" message, which we cover below.

For a photo printer, though, the black is rarely the cartridge you run out of. The 64XL black and tri-color combo at $43.99 covers both slots for less than a single genuine 64XL black, and the remanufactured HP 64XL tri-color on its own is $24.99 for 415 pages, against $68.89 genuine. If you print photos, keep a spare tri-color on hand. We also stock a 64XL MICR black for check printing, which is a separate product for a separate job.

Dynamic security, HP+ and the "cartridge problem" message

HP 64 is an integrated-printhead cartridge: the chip and nozzles are part of the cartridge body, so remanufacturers reuse HP's own chip. HP's dynamic security language says its printers are "intended to work only with cartridges that have new or reused HP chips" and that remanufactured cartridges retaining HP circuitry are "unaffected by dynamic security" (HP support forum, quoting HP's policy). Firmware updates are not the risk on the ENVY Photo or Tango.

HP+ is the risk on the ENVY Inspire. HP's HP+ FAQ says an activated printer requires Original HP ink for its lifetime, and HP does not document a way back. If your Inspire was enrolled, remanufactured ink will be refused regardless of chip, and your cheaper option is HP's own Instant Ink, which we compare in our Instant Ink cost post.

The family's signature complaint is the ENVY Photo 7855's "remove and reinstall the cartridge" or "cartridge problem" message with 64XL black. HP's own community threads show it happening with genuine HP 64XL, with HP replacing cartridges and sometimes printers (HP community thread). With third-party units the usual cause is dirty or worn contacts on a heavily recycled core. Before assuming the cartridge is bad, wipe the copper contacts with a lint-free cloth, reseat it and power-cycle the printer. If it persists with one of ours, our 1-year return window covers a replacement.

How to choose an HP 64 cartridge

  • Always buy the XL. Standard HP 64 black is 13 cents a page, genuine 64XL is 10.5 cents, and remanufactured 64XL is about 4 cents.
  • If you own an ENVY Inspire 7255e or 7955e, check whether HP+ was activated at setup; HP+ printers accept Original HP ink only.
  • Photo printing drains the tri-color fast. Stock a spare 64XL tri-color before a big photo job.
  • Prefer remanufactured over "compatible" for an integrated-printhead cartridge; you want HP's original printhead and chip.
  • If the printer says "remove and reinstall," clean the contacts and reseat before blaming the cartridge; genuine HP 64XL triggers this too.
  • Buy from a US seller with a 1- to 2-year guarantee; marketplace combo packs often have none.

HP 64 Compatible Ink FAQs

Does the HP ENVY Photo 7855 accept remanufactured HP 64XL ink?

Yes. The ENVY Photo 7855 is not an HP+ printer, and HP states that cartridges which keep the original HP chip are unaffected by dynamic security. Remanufactured 64XL cartridges reuse HP's chip and printhead.

How many pages does HP 64XL print?

HP rates 64XL black at up to 600 pages and 64XL tri-color at up to 415 pages under ISO testing at about 5% coverage. Photo prints use far more ink, so real-world yields on an ENVY Photo are lower.

How much can I save with remanufactured HP 64XL?

Genuine 64XL black is $62.89 at Staples, or about 10.5 cents per page. Castle Ink's remanufactured 64XL black is $23.99, roughly 4 cents per page, a saving of about 62% per cartridge.

Why does my printer say "cartridge problem" with a new HP 64XL?

This error is common on the ENVY Photo series with both genuine and third-party cartridges. Clean the contacts, reseat the cartridge and power-cycle the printer; if it persists, ask the seller for a replacement under warranty.

The bottom line

For any HP 64 printer that is not an HP+-enrolled ENVY Inspire, the remanufactured HP 64XL black at $23.99 for 600 pages saves about 62% against genuine, and the 64XL combo at $43.99 is the better buy for a photo printer. LD Products is a dollar cheaper on the black; the difference between us is shipping, returns and support rather than price.

Related reading: best compatible ink brands, compatible vs OEM HP ink, is XL ink worth it, best compatible ink for HP 67, all HP 64 ink cartridges, and our HP ink cartridge collection.

Written and reviewed by — Founder of Castle Ink, 20+ years in the printer & imaging supplies industry.

Castle Ink

Save up to 70% on HP ink

Remanufactured cartridges with a lifetime replacement guarantee. Order by 4 PM ET and it ships the same day. Free US shipping over $50.