How Much Do You Actually Save with Remanufactured Toner? Real Numbers

"Remanufactured toner saves you money" is the marketing line. But how much, really? We pulled the current numbers for the five toner cartridges our customers ask about most — including how many pages each produces, so you can see actual cost per page, not just the sticker price.

Prices below are what you'd pay at major retailers (Staples, Best Buy, HP.com, Amazon) for OEM vs. what we charge for remanufactured versions. Page yields are manufacturer-stated figures.

HP 26A / CF226A (standard-yield black)

Used by: HP LaserJet Pro M402, MFP M426

• OEM price: ~$100
• Page yield: 3,100 pages
• OEM cost per page: $0.032
• Remanufactured at Castle Ink: ~$45
• Reman cost per page: $0.014
• Savings per cartridge: ~$55 (55% off)
• Annual savings if you go through 4 cartridges: $220

HP 58A / CF258A

Used by: HP LaserJet Pro M404, MFP M428

• OEM price: ~$115
• Page yield: 3,000 pages
• OEM cost per page: $0.038
• Remanufactured at Castle Ink: ~$55 (with chip)
• Reman cost per page: $0.018
• Savings per cartridge: ~$60 (52% off)

Note: the 58A is one of the cartridges HP has most aggressively chipped. Make sure any remanufactured 58A you buy includes a replacement chip — check the listing carefully.

Brother TN730 (standard) / TN760 (high yield)

Used by: Brother HL-L2350DW, HL-L2370DW, HL-L2390DW, MFC-L2710DW, MFC-L2750DW, DCP-L2550DW

• TN730 OEM: ~$80, 1,200 pages, $0.066/page
• TN760 OEM (high yield): ~$105, 3,000 pages, $0.035/page
• TN760 remanufactured: ~$35, $0.012/page
• Savings per TN760: ~$70 (66% off)

The Brother TN730/760 is the single biggest opportunity to save. OEM prices are inflated, and remanufactured quality is consistently good because the Brother cartridge design is forgiving to work with. We stock the TN830XL for newer models and TN760 for the popular L2350/L2370 series.

Canon 055 / 055H

Used by: Canon Color imageCLASS MF741Cdw, MF743Cdw, LBP664Cdw

• OEM 055 set of 4 (BK/C/M/Y): ~$320
• OEM 055H high-yield set: ~$540
• Remanufactured 055H set: ~$180
• Savings per set: ~$360 (67% off)

Canon color toner sets are where savings become dramatic. A single OEM 055H set of four costs more than some of the printers that use them.

HP 414A/414X color set

Used by: HP Color LaserJet Pro M454, MFP M479

• OEM 414A set: ~$440
• OEM 414X high-yield set: ~$630
• Remanufactured 414X set: ~$220
• Savings per set: ~$410 (65% off)

The real-world annual savings for a small office

A small office printing ~12,000 pages a year on a Brother HL-L2350DW (roughly 4 TN760 cartridges annually) will spend:

• OEM toner: $420 per year
• Remanufactured toner: $140 per year
• Annual savings: $280

For a business running 3–4 printers, that's $800–1,100 per year staying in the operating budget instead of going to Brother.

What could go wrong

To be clear-eyed: remanufactured toner isn't identical to OEM. Realistic differences:

• Slight variation in page yield. A cartridge rated at 3,000 pages may deliver 2,700–3,000 in practice. The cost-per-page math still works out dramatically in your favor.
• Occasional DOA cartridges. Rare but real. Every reputable remanufacturer (including us) replaces these free — which is why buying from someone with a clear warranty matters.
• Firmware blocks on HP laser printers. Same issue as inkjet — keep auto-updates off.

What you don't sacrifice: print quality for normal office documents. Remanufactured black toner produces text that's visually indistinguishable from OEM for reports, invoices, letters, and forms. Where OEM has a slight edge is high-gradient color photography on laser printers, which is a niche use case.

Ready to compare your specific cartridge?

Browse our HP toner, Brother toner, and Canon toner collections — or email us your printer model if you're not sure which cartridge you need.